An In-Depth Review: Best Elizabeth Strout Books

An open book on top of a stack against a blue backdrop

In the world of contemporary literature, Elizabeth Strout stands out as an author of great renown. To introduce new readers to her work or to guide seasoned fans in their next pick from her collection, we’ve analyzed and ranked her books. This evaluation is based on multiple review platforms, namely Goodreads, Amazon, and LibraryThing. Each title has been scored and compared to provide you an insight into what makes each one unique, with the aim of helping you decide which book to dive into next.

This should not be taken as a definitive judgment on the superiority of one book over another, as the beauty of Strout’s work lies in their diversity. Still, the ranking provides an entertaining endeavor for fans and a helpful guide for newcomers. Now, let’s dive into the magical literary world of Elizabeth Strout.

If you enjoy Elizabeth Strout’s books, you may also like exploring some of the best soccer books of all time, offering exciting insights into the world’s most popular sport.

Rankings and Reviews of Elizabeth Strout’s Top Books

The cover of 'Anything Is Possible' by Elizabeth Strout

My Name Is Lucy Barton (2016)

Scores from Review Websites:

  • Goodreads: 6;
  • Amazon: 6;
  • LibraryThing: 3.

In this stirring tale, Lucy Barton, a woman recovering from a seemingly routine surgery, is visited by her estranged mother. As they reconnect over tales from Lucy’s childhood, we see the threads of tension, ambition, and longing that have drawn the shape of Lucy’s life come to the fore. Lucy’s journey to escape her challenging upbringing, her quest to become a writer, her marriage, and her adoration for her two daughters constitute the heart of this story, told in a voice that is human, insightful, and memorable.

The Burgess Boys (2013)

Scores from Review Websites:

  • Goodreads: 5;
  • Amazon: 4;
  • LibraryThing: 4.

The Burgess Boys, Jim and Bob, have left their Maine hometown and their painful past behind, carving out lives in New York City. Their sister Susan, however, has remained at home and now needs their help with her troubled son. As they respond to her plea and return to their roots, old wounds open, and the brothers must face the long-standing dynamics that have defined their relationship in unforeseen ways, leading to lasting change.

Amy and Isabelle (1998)

Scores from Review Websites:

  • Goodreads: 4;
  • Amazon: 1;
  • LibraryThing: 5.

Elizabeth Strout’s debut novel masterfully examines the fraught relationship between a mother and her teenage daughter. In the close-knit mill town of Shirley Falls, secrets are hard to keep, and when Isabelle discovers her daughter Amy’s hidden sexual life, it drives a chilling wedge between them. To mend this rift, Isabelle must confront and expose her shameful past.

Abide with Me (2006)

Scores from Review Websites:

  • Goodreads: 2;
  • Amazon: 2;
  • LibraryThing: 6.

In this poignant exploration of faith and grief, Tyler Caskey, a minister in West Annett, suffers a devastating loss that shakes his faith to its core. This tale delves into how Tyler, slowly losing grip over his spiritual convictions and personal relationships, struggles to connect with his young daughter and his congregation, revealing the human side of faith and the struggle for redemption.

Anything is Possible (2017)

Scores from Review Websites:

  • Goodreads: 1;
  • Amazon: 4;
  • LibraryThing: 1.

The narratives in ‘Anything is Possible’ revolve around themes of human frailty, resilience, and the capacity for change. The stories intertwine to create a complex yet realistic portrait of a community and its inhabitants, exploring the boundaries of family and friendship.

Olive Kitteridge (2008)

Scores from Review Websites:

  • Goodreads: 2;
  • Amazon: 2;
  • LibraryThing: 2.

The town of Crosby, Maine, serves as the backdrop for this moving narrative, bringing out all the grandeur, despair, hope, and jealousy that make up human life. At the center is Olive Kitteridge, a retired schoolteacher navigating the changing dynamics in her town and within her own relationships while battling her own internal struggles and revelations.

Elizabeth Strout: The Writer Behind the Books

A woman speaking into a microphone with a painting behind her

Elizabeth Strout has captured readers’ hearts with her ability to weave intricate character studies against the backdrop of everyday America. Her ability to create characters that resonate with readers long after they’ve closed the book is a testament to her skill.

The influence of Strout’s work is seen not just in the awards and recognitions she has received but also in the impact on her readers. She challenges readers to delve deeper into their understanding of human nature, relationships, and the world around them.

Conclusion

Elizabeth Strout’s books are characterized by their vivid portrayal of human life and relationships. Drawing on the every day and the extraordinary, her narratives are a testament to the depths of human emotion and the complexities of life. Be it through the examination of strained relationships or deep character studies, Strout’s stories always leave their mark on readers. We hope this comprehensive guide has offered you an extensive overview of her work and a more in-depth understanding of what makes each of her novels unique.

Thomas Jennifer

You may also like...